THE FIRST ISSUE of “American Gardener,” the newly redesigned member journal of the American Horticultural Society, arrived not too long ago, and in it are numerous good reads—together with an article by Nancy Lawson, a.okay.a. The Humane Gardener.
She writes concerning the folly, and hazard, of falling prey to the guarantees of these mosquito-control providers you’re most likely seeing marketed about now—and the place mosquitoes match into the larger environmental image, anyhow. (Above, a 1905 illustration of mosquitoes within the Culex genus by E.A. Goeldi; picture from Wikimedia Commons.)
Nancy Lawson, whom you might know as “The Humane Gardener”—the title of considered one of her books—is a naturalist and habitat guide based mostly in Maryland. Nancy promotes animal-friendly planting methods and challenges us to sharpen our consciousness that we’re not alone on the market, however really only one a part of a a lot greater image. Nancy’s newer e-book is known as “Wildscape.”
Plus: Remark within the field close to the underside of the web page to enter to win a replica of Nancy’s e-book “Wildscape” (affiliate hyperlink).
Learn alongside as you hearken to the Could 19, 2025 version of my public-radio present and podcast utilizing the participant beneath. You may subscribe to all future editions on Apple Podcasts (iTunes) or Spotify (and browse my archive of podcasts right here).
mosquito misconceptions, with nancy lawson
Obtain file | Play in new window |
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify
Margaret Roach: I used to be glad to see what you wrote about within the first of the revamped problems with the American Horticultural Society’s journal. In order that was nice to see that they needed to do this kind of a subject. All of those “Acquired to kill the insect” form of promoting pitches make me a bit loopy, I suppose as a result of my identify is Roach, huh? [Laughter.] However I really like the lead of your story, the place you quote a number of the promoting campaigns for mosquito-fogging providers and stuff which have slogans like, “Outdoors is enjoyable once more,” “The one good mosquito is a lifeless one,” after which the one, “Youngsters love butterflies, not ticks and mosquitoes. Battle again to guard your loved ones and pets.” So what will we consider all that?
Nancy Lawson: Yeah. Effectively, that final one actually acquired me, as a result of there’s an image with it of two youngsters, like toddler age, wanting with a wanting glass right into a jar, and there’s a blue morpho butterfly Photoshopped in. The entire thing is Photoshopped, and it’s exhibiting these youngsters simply enraptured by bugs that don’t even happen right here. After which, yeah, it’s all form of mirage from begin to end, by way of how they market these providers, and make folks really feel comfy and protected. And even people who find themselves involved about native ecologies oftentimes don’t understand as a result of they see these firms because the authority.
Margaret: And I imply, this got here up for me when some readers requested me about tick providers. “Oh, we’re having this utilized to our yard as a result of it’s going to eliminate all of the ticks.” And there’s ones with ants [laughter] and are you aware what I imply? Spiders! And it’s like, oh my goodness. I imply there’s so many, and these claims: One is extra fantastical than one other. And loads of that’s based mostly on the truth that they speak concerning the merchandise that they’re going to make use of being “pure,” however what they don’t discuss is that they’re not selective. That they’re not simply aimed toward one species.
Nancy: Precisely. They actually hype up that their product is—they are saying it’s pyrethrins, which is chrysanthemum-derived, which can also be very dangerous; it’s a broad-spectrum insecticide anyway, though it’s pure. However normally they’re not even utilizing that. They’re utilizing the synthetically produced model of that, that are pyrethroids, they usually’re structurally simply far more poisonous and longer-lasting. So that they’re marketed to final weeks at a time, as much as three weeks.
And so these firms will say, “Effectively, we’re solely concentrating on vegetation the place the bugs are.” “We’re solely spraying when the bees aren’t out.” It’s early within the morning or late within the day or one thing like that. However as we all know, initially, there’s tons of nocturnal bugs, crepuscular bugs, and there’s numerous bugs through the day which can be nocturnal which can be roosting in the identical vegetation that mosquitoes do, like fireflies.
And after I interviewed Aaron Anderson on the Xerces Society for that article, he gave the actually good instance of a leafcutter bee who’s going to a type of handled areas to chop a chunk of a redbud or a chunk of a Virginia creeper or a rose or a few of these vegetation that they love, and taking it again with them to their nest. So it’s not solely probably harming the grownup, but additionally the larvae, as a result of there’s nonetheless that chemical on that leaf for probably weeks at a time.
Margaret: So this residual impact of those pyrethroids can kill bees, butterflies, caterpillars, fireflies, many different bugs. And I imagine there’s additionally some analysis proof about potential human influence. So it’s not like these are one thing that’s good for everyone, all residing creatures [laughter]. [Above, a bumble bee.]
Nancy: Yeah, precisely.
Margaret: However this indiscriminate mosquito fogging and so forth, I used to be fascinated in your article to see that there’s many species of mosquitoes. So a mosquito isn’t a mosquito isn’t a mosquito; it’s not like a one creature. And that solely what I believe you stated, 12 of them, of these 200 [in the U.S.], are those that there could also be illness points with. So loads of mosquitoes we don’t have hurt from, any critical hurt apart from an itchy chunk, perhaps. But additionally they’re plentiful they usually’re extremely essential within the meals chain for lots of animals, of different bugs and I believe particularly of birds and so forth, who eats mosquitoes.
Nancy: So there’s 3,500 worldwide, after which there’s 200 within the U.S. and outlying territories, and solely round 12 are thought of to be illness vectors. And so many different ones, they may be “nuisances” to us, however they’re not really harming us, however they’re feeding—all the mosquitoes are feeding—birds, bats, frogs, dragonflies particularly, damselflies. [Below, a common whitetail skimmer dragonfly.]
Margaret: Proper. That’s what I used to be making an attempt to recollect, dragonflies; in fact, in fact.
Nancy: And what I discovered actually fascinating after I wrote this piece was the Boulder instance, in Boulder, Colo., of what they’re doing. They usually discovered that the damselflies and dragonflies have actually simply an enormous function in mosquito management at their websites that they monitor. They usually had a West Nile outbreak within the early 2000s in that area. They usually since then have this actually complete program within the metropolis of Boulder, however they don’t spray any adulticides. So that they’re not spraying, they’re not concentrating on grownup mosquitoes, as a result of actually that doesn’t get on the supply of the issue.
Margaret: And it’s so expensive in different methods environmentally.
Nancy: And so they’re monitoring. They’ve 19 traps across the metropolis, after which they’ve 300 wetlands that they monitor, they usually’ll monitor for a sure threshold of threat. So so long as the variety of contaminated mosquitoes stays beneath that threshold, there’s a really low threat of transmission to people.
And they also simply spot-treat, however very, very judiciously, with Bti. And that’s that bacterial larvicide [Bacillus thuringiensis subspecies israelensis], which lots of people will find out about, however they spot-treat the larvae with that. And once they discover that there’s an space that perhaps there aren’t sufficient predators current, there isn’t sufficient biodiversity current, and there are I believe it was like 10 or extra mosquito Culex mosquito larvae in a pattern. And the 2 species in that space that trigger illness are two within the Culex genus. And so in the event that they discover 10 or extra or one thing in a bit pattern, then they’ll use some granules of Bti.
However what they discovered is that surrounding communities that spray really go generally many orders of magnitude above the brink for threat to people. They usually’re really spraying adulticides on a regular basis.
And they also had been engaged on, after I talked to them, placing collectively their knowledge to do a paper on this. And their thought was that there have been two causes: that not spraying saved round all these different mosquitoes that don’t carry illness and that had been good competitors for the 2 disease-carrying species. So that they take up egg-laying websites, they usually are also consuming algae as larvae and microorganisms and stuff, they usually’re competing principally in the identical area of interest for house and assets. And if you take all of them away, then that implies that these Culex species can are available in and proliferate. And in addition loads of these Culex species are extra proof against the adulticides. And in order that’s one other subject with spraying, is that you simply’re fostering-
Margaret: There was a line in your article, I believe it stated it could actually take 1,000,000 droplets of insecticide simply to achieve one mosquito.
Nancy: [Laughter.] That was a Cornell examine. So the place are all these different droplets going?
Margaret: Effectively, we all know: They’re killing numerous different issues. And once more, the residual impact for weeks afterward and so forth. And once more, essential to do not forget that this, people, is a meals chain. Precisely.
And so once more, I don’t love a mosquito chunk. It’s irritating. And I need to swat at them, too, when one comes at me or no matter [laughter]. However if you happen to’re going to sit down on the patio and have supper, put a fan out. Have you learnt what I imply? Let’s attempt to consider different issues that we will do to handle a few of these conditions, quite than assume and purchase into the baloney, actually, that there’s some form of cure-all. Like, “Hey, don’t fear about mosquitoes. Simply pay us the cash to do that.”
And I’m sorry to sound stuffed with disdain for a few of these guarantees of a few of these applications, however I really feel that means as a result of it causes loads of different hurt. And that’s what’s by no means revealed within the gross sales pitch, that this different hurt goes to cascade down from this motion that you simply’re taking, and the buyer doesn’t perceive that. And I believe loads of the shoppers, in the event that they did perceive that, would perhaps attempt a special strategy. And that’s why we’re speaking about it at the moment. I don’t suppose folks know that, and I believe the promoting promise sounds good, proper?
Nancy: Proper. And there are individuals who will push again on the concept as a result of it’s true: birds and bats alone aren’t taking good care of mosquitoes. They eat mosquitoes, however they eat loads of different issues, too. Nevertheless it’s the entire assortment of our wild neighbors on the market doing the job, and animals like dragonflies and damselflies are consuming loads of mosquitoes. They’re additionally feeding the birds.
That was one other factor within the Boulder analysis, is that in areas the place you’re taking away so lots of these dragonflies and damselflies by taking away their meals, their mosquito prey, then you definitely’re additionally taking birds away, as a result of the dragonflies and damselflies are in flip fowl prey. And so that you’re decreasing all the best way up the chain the biodiversity, and the various layers of ecological well being.
Margaret: And there are issues that we will do inside our personal little habitat, so to talk. And I do know folks have heard this earlier than, and it sounds perhaps tiresome, but it surely actually does make a distinction. Standing water, even a really small quantity, is an issue, and is a spot the place this replica exercise can occur. So that you’re inviting extra mosquitoes if you happen to go away an inch of water in a bucket or no matter, or once more, puddles and issues like that.
And even if you happen to don’t rinse your fowl bathtub, that water can develop into a spot the place they reproduce. And so we will make a distinction in our personal rapid surrounding.
I’ve water gardens, too, water gardens that I’ve had for greater than 30 years, in-ground water gardens. And I’ve seasonal troughs, massive troughs of water, that I put out form of as container gardens, so to talk. However they’re water. And other people at all times, once they come to backyard visits right here, they’re at all times, “Oh, you will need to have horrible mosquitoes.” And I’m like, “No, I can’t bear in mind the final time I acquired a mosquito chunk.”
Now, one factor is I’m an upland website. I’m on a hill; I’m not a lowland website, so I don’t have loads of massive quantities of standing water and issues like that. However I do have water and I’m in a space the place it rains a good quantity and so forth. So I attribute it to the truth that I even have tons of frogs and tons of birds. And I imply, as a result of I invite all of them in with different approaches to form of habitat-style gardening for all these many years, and I believe all of them assist. They’re the helper creatures, as a result of once more, it’s a meals chain.
Nancy: I get the identical feedback. And one yr within the fall, I seen in October, I acquired a couple of bites. And I noticed it was, I believe, as a result of the dragonflies had been leaving and a number of the birds had been migrating. [Above, the pond at Nancy’s garden in Maryland; below, a common green darner dragonfly.]
Margaret: So standing water and cleansing our fowl baths, not letting water puddle and pool and be in issues like containers right here and there and so forth, that’s simply standing. What else can we do? I imply, I do know lots of people discuss making form of a bucket lure, and even Doug Tallamy recommends generally making a bucket lure stuffed midway I believe with water and a few straw in it and so forth.
Nancy: After which that’s a spot the place mosquitoes are going to need to lay eggs, and so it’s good and stagnant. However lots of people, they’ll put the Bti dunks in there.
Margaret: This, it appears to be like like a giant pill, like a giant big aspirin or no matter [laughter], but it surely’s a Bti, it’s this pure insecticide, so to talk, this biologic.
Nancy: Yeah. And so I requested the Xerces Society about it. I’ve at all times had a priority about that as a result of folks may even put it in ponds. They’ll put it in fowl baths, and is it actually protected for everyone however mosquitoes? How can that be? So I did ask Doug a few years in the past, as a result of I’m concerned with our native Bee Metropolis, Howard County Bee Metropolis in Maryland, and we had been speaking about placing collectively bucket kits. And I had a priority about that, as a result of I had learn that midges may very well be affected, they usually’re actually good fowl meals and stuff. And Doug stated they wouldn’t be affected most likely as a result of they lay eggs in mud within the backside of marshes and ponds.
However then after I talked to the Xerces Society only in the near past, they stated they only suggest that individuals as an alternative simply do the bucket, simply put some straw or some grass in there and a few water, and dump it periodically each few days. And don’t use a Bti as a result of we don’t know the impact of Bti on the soil and all of the organisms within the soil. And in addition it does hurt crane flies.
And so far as folks placing it in ponds and such, I imply, there’s a certain quantity of tolerance that we need to have, too. There’s been influence proven on dragonfly and damselfly larvae, but it surely’s considered as a result of they’re being disadvantaged of their mosquito prey when Bti is used. So I believe it’s a type of issues on a spectrum where-
Margaret: If we don’t want it, we might go away it off the to-do checklist. And once more, if the bucket turns into this sort of funky place with a bit water in it they usually’re attracted to only the straw within the water, and also you dump that each few days such as you’re saying, then the eggs by no means hatch. It’s by no means left there lengthy sufficient for profitable replica, and also you skip the Bti. So good. So much less is extra. I imply, that’s higher, safer.
However I do suppose loads of us most likely have mosquito locations the place they wish to be, a bit little bit of water right here and there as a result of it rains and also you overlook there’s your weed bucket that you simply overlooked wherever [laughter], by the compost heap, and it has an inch of water. Have you learnt what I imply? And people are the issues and that may contribute to the issue. So these little issues that we will do to be a bit extra vigilant, I believe as nicely.
Nancy: And that’s the very Number one advice.
Margaret: And to me, it’s the identical considering when everybody I do know desires a tick system, to snap their fingers and have all of it go away, but it surely’s vigilance. It’s solely vigilance, the scientists inform us to this point, we don’t have a magic bullet for ticks. And their populations come and get increased and decrease and so forth. However there’s nothing that has been proven in analysis to—it doesn’t matter what the businesses let you know who need to apply some product to your yard or put traps or no matter—that’s going to do the job on a scale, a much bigger scale like an entire neighborhood or something like that. They’re going to be there.
And so it’s like, nicely, then you understand what? It’s my accountability, particularly as a gardener, to be vigilant about my very own self-care, proper?
Nancy: Sure.
Margaret: Every time I’m going out and are available again in and to have a protocol and to take heed to it, as a result of I want to guard myself as a result of I can’t, once more, snap my fingers or pay somebody an amount of cash to make all of it go away, the hazard go away.
Nancy: And it’s undoubtedly comprehensible that in some areas of the world, in some areas, it’s a much bigger concern than in others, and a much bigger threat. However for instance, the place I reside, it’s a really low threat of truly contracting one thing.
Margaret: You imply from mosquitoes?
Nancy. Yeah. And so that concept of a sure tolerance degree, too, I imply, nobody desires to be bitten, however such as you’re saying, you may apply repellents, too, and you may put on lengthy sleeves.
Margaret: And once more, if you wish to dine outdoors, put a fan if you happen to don’t have a display room or one thing like that to make use of.
Nancy: The fan is nice. Mosquitoes can’t fly on the wind.
Margaret: Proper, precisely. So that may be a extremely good, and it doesn’t should be on excessive, both. It may be low, or a few little small ones. It makes an enormous distinction.
Nancy: And you’ll be outdoors quite than an hour earlier than and after sundown or once they’re most energetic, you could be outdoors at completely different instances when potential. There’s various things that you are able to do. In case you can’t do all of it, there’s sure issues you could attempt.
Margaret: So I simply need to ask, let’s discuss one thing completely happy [laughter]. What’s thrilling happening in your wild world down there in your individual habitat, in your Maryland backyard? Any tasks below means or something you’re significantly centered on this spring? [Above, a resident frog at Nancy’s garden.]
Nancy: Yeah. Effectively, I’m preparing for some excursions.
Margaret: Oh, boy [laughter].
Nancy: And I normally can’t see who’s nesting. I can form of inform the place they’re nesting by their exercise, however I hate to disturb and look too carefully generally, as a result of afraid I’m going to freak out the birds. However proper now there’s a cardinal couple nesting within the coral honeysuckle that’s rising up the staghorn sumac that’s proper outdoors my slider in my workplace. And it’s so candy, as a result of I can hear them calling to one another, and I can see her situating herself all day lengthy. And it has made me marvel, do they like this specific place lots as a result of the flowers look a lot like her? I imply, her head has the little purple down the again that appears similar to… And all of the petals are interwoven on the surface of the online. I imply all of the flowers. It’s like, I don’t know in the event that they decide them or they fell in, however they’re all on the surface of her nest. So it’s so candy.
Margaret: Effectively, I’ve an irate feminine robin. I had a backyard tour on Saturday and 300 and one thing folks got here, and robin was proper on the again porch really in a coral honeysuckle as nicely, nesting [laughter]. And he or she was very indignant that I allowed guests within the property presently. “Margaret, I filed a grievance, Margaret,” she stated, so…
Effectively, I’m at all times actually glad to talk to you, and once more, I used to be actually glad to see your article in “American Gardener.” Thanks. And thanks for citing this essential matter. I hope I’ll speak to you once more earlier than later. Let’s not let so lengthy go by.
Nancy: Yeah, thanks a lot. I actually respect you protecting this matter too, Margaret.
(Photos from Nancy Lawson, besides as famous.)
extra from nancy, and extra on mosquitoes
enter to win a signed copy of ‘wildscape’
I’LL BUY a replica of “Wildscape” by Nancy Lawson for one fortunate reader. All it’s important to do to enter is reply this query within the feedback field beneath:
Ever used a bucket with straw, or a Bti dunk, or a fan outdoors or another mosquito-managing tactic in your backyard?
No reply, or feeling shy? Simply say one thing like “depend me in” and I’ll, however a reply is even higher. I’ll choose a random winner after entries shut Tuesday, Could 27, 2025 at midnight. Good luck to all.
(Disclosure: As an Amazon Affiliate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
favor the podcast model of the present?
MY WEEKLY public-radio present, rated a “top-5 backyard podcast” by “The Guardian” newspaper within the UK, started its fifteenth yr in March 2024. It’s produced at Robin Hood Radio, the smallest NPR station within the nation. Pay attention domestically within the Hudson Valley (NY)-Berkshires (MA)-Litchfield Hills (CT) Mondays at 8:30 AM Japanese, rerun at 8:30 Saturdays. Or play the Could 17, 2025 present utilizing the participant close to the highest of this transcript. You may subscribe to all future editions on iTunes/Apple Podcasts or Spotify (and browse my archive of podcasts right here).
