EVERY GARDENER has actually heard the rallying cry every latest autumn to “go away the leaves,” invoking us to go gentler with our cleanup to assist a variety of helpful invertebrates who name the fallen leaves their dwelling.
Now a just lately revealed analysis examine calculates simply what the impacts of leaf removing are to which organisms, and in addition presents insights into how and the place in our landscapes we will go away the leaves to create habitat with probably the most constructive influence.
Max Ferlauto, the Maryland state entomologist, is without doubt one of the scientists who performed the brand new analysis, and in March this yr, Max and Karin Burghardt, an ecologist and affiliate professor on the College of Maryland-Faculty Park, revealed analysis on the impacts of leaf removing ensuing from their two-year examine in 20 residential suburban Maryland yards. On the podcast we talked about their takeaways, and the way the info they gathered will help inform gardeners searching for to develop their very own extra ecological fall cleanup plans.
Learn alongside as you take heed to the Oct. 20, 2025 version of my public-radio present and podcast utilizing the participant under. You possibly can subscribe to all future editions on Apple Podcasts (iTunes) or Spotify (and browse my archive of podcasts right here).
the impacts of leaf removing, with max ferlauto
Obtain file | Play in new window |
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify
Margaret Roach: Yeah. So we did a latest “New York Instances” backyard column collectively about your newest analysis with Karin Burghardt, and I believe I stated to you on the time, that I’d heard about leaves the leaves, however this was like: go away the leaves, by the numbers. [Laughter.] It’s such as you actually collected knowledge. It was superb. So inform us, how did the examine take form? What did you do? What was the protocol, so to talk?
Max Ferlauto: Yeah, positive. So we use this stuff referred to as emergence traps [above], that are these tents that you simply mainly place over the earth and something that emerges from that piece of land will get collected. And so in these suburban yards, as you talked about, we positioned these emergence traps over areas the place leaves have been raked away and the place leaves have been retained. So we have been in a position to actually see the whole lot that was rising from the bottom after the winter, which is the time frame that we’re involved about in the course of the leaf litter removing interval.
Margaret: So there have been pairs, so to talk, of those traps. And one had leaves, one space had leaves, and one didn’t in every case. And the way huge have been the spots? How huge have been the traps?
Max: So we manipulated the leaf litter in a single meter sq. quadrats, and the emergence traps over these quadrats in areas the place we eliminated or retained leaves.
Margaret: In order that’s probably not very huge. And but once I learn the numbers, I imply it’s a bit of bigger than a sq. yard, sure, a sq. meter?
Max: Yeah, a sq. meter.
Margaret: So it’s not miles and miles and miles. And but once I learn the numbers come spring, or in March once you put these emergence traps up by way of, I suppose what, the top of June was it annually?
Max: Sure. March by way of June, March by way of the top of June, and we collected nearly 2,000 bugs rising bugs and spiders rising from that sq. meter of yard. [Above. Max with a waved sphinx moth.]
Margaret: In every one that had leaves.
Max: Sure.
Margaret: I imply, that’s loads of life [laughter]. That’s loads of life.
Max: You don’t take into consideration your yard producing that a lot abundance in biodiversity. However that’s what we discovered.
Margaret: And which organisms have been you counting? You weren’t counting like earthworms or-?
Max: So earthworms and decomposing species like springtails, we had much more of these. These have been simply butterflies and moths, helpful parasitic wasps, spiders, beetles and flies.
Margaret: O.Okay.
Max: And mainly once you eliminated leaves, we noticed a lower in loads of these teams. So once you eliminated leaves, we discovered that the common abundance of butterflies and moths was decreased by about 45 p.c.
Margaret: Forty-five p.c. Oh!
Max: Spider emergence declined by 56 p.c, and beetle emergence declined by 24 p.c. So we’re seeing that sure, these small sections of our yard, which produce so many bugs and helpful species, when you take away the leaves, we’re seeing declines there.
Margaret: So now individuals are most likely like, effectively, however what’s… You didn’t point out parasitic wasps simply then; you had talked about them earlier. However I’m a gardener—why am I interested by spiders? A variety of that is in regards to the checks-and-balances methods, proper? It’s like the entire system needs to be in place. We’ve all heard within the go away the leaves marketing campaign, we’ve particularly heard in regards to the butterflies and moths and their caterpillars, which then in fact are the first meals supply for child birds, particularly songbirds. And that’s so critically essential, and that’s been highlighted to us as a part of this marketing campaign. But it surely’s not fairly that easy. It’s not simply these Lepidopterans. [Above, a marbled orb weaver spider.]
Max: In your yard, you wish to have a thriving ecosystem, and meaning interested by the prey and the predators, and that happens on the insect stage, similar to it happens for mammals and birds. So sure, it’s actually essential to have butterflies and caterpillars to feed birds, but additionally it’s nice to have helpful biocontrol.
These are pure enemies that we have now in our yards that handle our pest issues. So issues like spiders, sure floor beetles, and undoubtedly parasitic wasps, that are tiny wasps; they will’t sting people, however they are going to lay their eggs in several pest species and cut back their numbers. So in case you have outbreaks of aphids or tobacco hornworms in your tomatoes, there are these parasitic wasps that can management these species.
Margaret: So if we do something to interrupt their success in our habitat, whether or not in a number of the instances by the numbers you talked about a pair minutes in the past, by not leaving the leaves, we decreased the proportion of emergent people of these teams of invertebrates.
Max: Spraying a pesticide, you would possibly do away with your downside within the quick time period. However in the long run, when you’re killing each the prey and the predator, finally that outbreak might come again even worse since you’re not going to have something to regulate it. Something that’s going to disrupt these meals chains in the long term, it’s going to be damaging.
Margaret: So if we wish someone to handle our aphids and our tobacco hornworms, we’d higher make it possible for the meals that they need is round [laughter], in any other case they’re not going to seek out our surroundings very engaging. I’m oversimplifying, however what I imply.
So there have been these declines in abundance, I believe you instructed me after we did the Instances story, you’d name it—the entire variety of people—and in addition fewer species you noticed in some instances.
Max: Yeah. So butterflies and moths had a discount in species richness or the variety of species by about 44 p.c.
Margaret: Oh my goodness.
Max: Yeah. And what we’re seeing was it wasn’t simply that the species richness was being decreased, but additionally the composition, the several types of the species that survived had modified. So particularly species that mine leaves, they’re referred to as leafminers, or species that overwinter as larvae or overwinter throughout the leaves, these are their life-history traits, we are saying these have been the species that have been harmed probably the most by eradicating leaves.
And on the predator facet, we discovered that the parasitoid wasps that feed on the leafminers and feed on the larvae which might be overwintering declined, similar to these prey species did as effectively. So we will see all the meals chain being disrupted by eradicating leaves. [Above, a mourning cloak butterfly; they overwinter as adults in leaf litter or under bark of trees.]
Margaret: A few years in the past, as gardeners—and I’ve been an natural gardener for many years—many, a few years in the past, there was a giant aha second the place it was like, don’t bag your leaves and put them out on the curb; be extra sustainable. Maintain them there. Make the most of these assets, construct your soil, use it as mulch, mow over it on the garden, shred it and let it decompose into the soil of your garden and blah, blah, blah. In different phrases, maintain it out of the landfill.
And that’s an excellent thought, that’s an excellent thought. But it surely doesn’t do what we’re simply speaking about: fostering, supporting this meals chain and creating habitat for all of those species to reside their life cycles out. So I’m going to nonetheless say, I consider that in comparison with sending it in a plastic bag to the landfill—some leaves might need to get possibly find yourself within the compost, or typically we simply have too many in sure configurations of our dwelling landscapes or no matter, to let all of them lie on each sq. inch.
However what ought to we be doing and what can we be doing, and which actions don’t assist these organisms that reside within the leaves and so forth? How do I do know what to do? What are my greatest and worst choices, so to talk [laughter]? As a result of it’s complicated.
Max: I’m an enormous proponent of composting leaves to your backyard, however as you talked about, by doing that, you’re going to be killing these overwintering species.
Margaret: Is the warmth; is it the warmth of the compost? What kills them?
Max: When you have a compost that’s working sturdy and sizzling, it’s going to kill these species. But additionally simply the depth of that compost pile goes to be disruptive as effectively.
So actually what we’re saying is you don’t have to depart the leaves over your whole yard—as I discussed, only a small sq. meter is producing so many bugs. So in case you have too many, you may compost what you must. However by leaving leaves and never composting them, you’re permitting for these life cycles of those totally different bugs we’re speaking about to finish.
And another issues you are able to do is take the leaves from an space that you simply don’t need them, and simply transfer them to a brand new space. A variety of the bugs are overwintering inside that leaf materials, so by transferring it, you’re simply mainly transferring them to a brand new dwelling over the winter.
Margaret: So transferring them entire, not shredded or not put by way of a machine of some form, however transferring them entire.
Max: We discovered that shredding leaves was nearly as dangerous as eradicating them and bagging them. So eradicating them entire, inserting them on the fringe of your yard, these are all various practices.
Margaret: So transferring them round. And when it comes to figuring out type of areas of most influence, constructive influence? I consider after we did the Instances story, we talked about interested by interested by: so right here I’ve made a pollinator backyard in my yard, let’s say. O.Okay., let me visualize all these creatures which might be dwelling in there within the fair-weather months. The place are they going to go and full their life cycle, procreate, no matter—what’s going to occur subsequent to them? And possibly take into consideration using that space or an adjoining space. Or if I’ve bushes and letting leaves lie beneath bushes and making a mattress beneath the bushes and issues like that.
What sort of methods—is it that form of pondering? Is that what you’re doing once you go searching? [Woolly bear caterpillars, above, the larval stage of the Isabelle tiger moth, overwinter in leaf litter.]
Max: And we did have a look at this and we discovered that leaving leaves in areas the place that they had beforehand been eliminated yr after yr was extra helpful than simply leaving them in an space the place you all the time go away them. In order that leaf materials is a habitat useful resource. And so by offering it in an in any other case barren space, you’re attracting these bugs to that protecting habitat, overwintering habitat. And the areas the place you might have flower gardens, the place you might have native plant gardens, these are all very best locations to retain your leaves.
Margaret: Yeah, I might suppose so. I imply, to me, that’s once more, after we spoke earlier than for the Instances story, that was form of what I used to be visualizing once you have been type of strolling me by way of the analysis and once I learn it by myself and so forth, after our conversations, I used to be form of visualizing. And the opposite factor I used to be visualizing is that, huh, O.Okay., on the fringe of my property, for instance, I’ve loads of mature bushes, as many individuals do. The most important bushes typically are alongside the property boundaries or no matter. And I believed, O.Okay., so these oaks, what if I could make these have their very own leaves beneath them? If I can create beds, so to talk and say, these are my security zones, these are locations the place I’m going to depart the leaves, as a result of that will appear to be a really pure, very best form of state of affairs.
Max: Yeah. There’s a time period that’s been mentioned referred to as “tender landings,” this concept the place you might have these areas beneath bushes and you retain them pure. And if you must transfer leaves to these areas, so long as you’re not creating large leaf piles and also you’re simply form of transferring them from one space to a different, you may create these protecting habitats, so that every one of these species that reside on the bushes in the course of the summer season and spring can transfer all the way down to its roots to the leaf layer that’s there in the course of the fall and winter. [More about creating soft landings.]
Margaret: And also you simply stated large leaf piles. So what we’re not speaking about is we’re not saying take each leaf entire, pile them on tarps and drag each single leaf in your property onto one mattress beneath one tree, so it’s a 7-foot-deep layer [laughter]. That’s not good.
Max: The bugs, they’re queued to seasonal adjustments, and in addition energetically, it’s very tough for them to climb out of a, as you stated, a 7-foot pile of leaves. So they need their surroundings to be as related as it might be on a forest flooring. So think about strolling by way of the woods on a hike. The leaf layer that you simply’re seeing round is the depth that we’re speaking about, so not deeper than that.
Margaret: So it’s not big, big, big piles of leaves, which additionally would smother a number of the herbaceous crops at that layer.
Max: Yeah, oxygen ranges are decrease. It’s simply not an excellent habitat to be an overwintering insect on the backside of a large pile of leaves.
Margaret: O.Okay. And equally, you’re not advocating that. Once more, utilizing this type of stroll round and look and take a look at to attract inferences by interested by the place are these creatures and the place are they going to go subsequent month and in three months and in six months, in different phrases, to have an entire yr to have their entire life cycle nevertheless lengthy it’s, and their subsequent era, subsequent era survive on this space the place I could have attracted them with my planting strategies and so forth. I imply, it’s a backyard in any case. So I’m not simply going to dump 7 toes deep of leaves behind my storage, both, proper? That’s not the entire reply.
Max: And it’s about interested by the entire life cycle, as you talked about. So when you’re attracting the bugs in the summertime along with your native crops or your pollinator flowers, you don’t wish to take away the habitat that they depend on over the winter. You’re mainly simply attracting them to kill them in a while. So it’s these areas that may be the most effective locations. Should you should go away your leaves in just one space, not the entire yard, these are the areas to prioritize.
Margaret: And also you simply talked about winter, and so loads of us, once more, it was go away the leaves, don’t clear up so scrupulously in fall, be a bit of messier, and so on., due to overwintering habitat. That is what we’ve realized thus far, as a result of once more, this can be a pretty new thought for lots of us, and we’re making an attempt to—and we’re not scientists, we don’t have your experience—we’re making an attempt to take all of it in.
So we’ve realized in regards to the overwintering-habitat thought and who’s in that leaf litter within the offseason, however it doesn’t finish there, does it? The significance of that habitat doesn’t finish there, does it, on the finish of winter?
Max: Yeah. Our experiment was to take away the leaves within the fall, after which we positioned these emergence traps within the spring to early summer season, however we didn’t discover any declines within the variety of bugs rising. So there was a thought that in some unspecified time in the future, possibly when the bottom hits 50 levels or all of those different potential instances, there was going to be a cliff, and a lot of the bugs would have emerged, and now we’re O.Okay. to take away our leaves.
We didn’t see that. We noticed that bugs stored on rising all through the summer season, in order that in July we have been truly getting extra bugs rising than we have been in March and April. So yeah, I might say that we’re speaking about overwintering, and that’s what we particularly studied, however it doesn’t seem like there’s a lot proof for there being a time the place the whole lot is emerged and it’s O.Okay. to wash up. A variety of species even have two generations, in order that they’ll have a era within the spring, after which they’ll even have one in late summer season. This leaf habitat is effective all yr spherical.
Margaret: Proper. Effectively, and if we give it some thought, we’re in a manner emulating or evoking this type of duff layer. The forest flooring you talked about earlier than is the closest factor we all know in habitats. So no person cleaned up the leaves there at any time [laughter]. Are you aware what I imply? It was a eternally factor. The detritivores, all the opposite creatures who you didn’t rely on this specific examine, however who we all know one thing about, they have been doing their work down under on the oldest stuff, which was getting integrated into the soil; the natural matter was getting integrated into the soil. So there was a relentless, once more, meals chain.
Max: Yeah. I imply, there are examples in historical past the place people have eliminated leaf litter from forests, like within the Center Ages. They’d use that materials for bedding for his or her livestock. And there’s been research which have proven that these areas the place the leaves have been eliminated for hundreds of years have decrease soil carbon ranges, even centuries after that follow had stopped. So the removing of this materials has long-lasting implications.
Margaret: Let’s speak a bit of bit extra about that, as a result of I believe a yr prior, I believe you revealed work about earlier analysis in regards to the soil carbon and about what you have been discovering. Was it from these identical properties, I consider, however earlier inferences?
Max: We checked out soil carbon and decomposition, and we discovered that areas the place leaves have been eliminated yr after yr as a historic follow inside yards had a discount of about 24 p.c of soil carbon was decreased.
Margaret: And the soil carbon helps in…what’s its position? It helps with-?
Max: Soil carbon, and soil natural matter actually are priceless as, I suppose you could possibly say, purveyors of various soil qualities. So soil carbon, having larger soil carbon, means your soil is extra nutritious. It means it holds water higher. It means structurally it’s much less compacted. After which in fact, pondering on the massive image, soil carbon is essential for carbon sequestration from our environment. So soil carbon is essential to the methods of earth.
Margaret: In order that was a number of the earlier takeaways, and that’s not fast. Such as you stated, within the locations the place you added leaves, you noticed not rapid, however in that very same season, you could possibly see creatures have been using it. Whereas repairing this lack of soil carbon doesn’t come again the subsequent yr.
Max: Proper, precisely. We might say that this is able to be a legacy impact of leaf removing. The carbon is being decreased by 24 p.c. It’s not coming again the subsequent yr.
Margaret: Or most likely anytime quickly.
Max: Yeah, precisely.
Margaret: Effectively, Max Ferlauto, I imply, the numbers actually did it for me. It made me wish to be taught increasingly and extra about every of the creatures and easy methods to assist them, and the intricate relationships between them and so forth. So I simply discovered it fascinating. I’m so glad to talk to you once more, and thanks for making time. I do know you’ve bought tons and much and much occurring, so thanks.
want the podcast model of the present?
MY WEEKLY public-radio present, rated a “top-5 backyard podcast” by “The Guardian” newspaper within the UK, started its sixteenth yr in March 2025. It’s produced at Robin Hood Radio, the smallest NPR station within the nation. Pay attention regionally within the Hudson Valley (NY)-Berkshires (MA)-Litchfield Hills (CT) Mondays at 8:30 AM Jap, rerun at 8:30 Saturdays. Or play the Oct. 20, 2025 present utilizing the participant close to the highest of this transcript. You possibly can subscribe to all future editions on iTunes/Apple Podcasts or Spotify (and browse my archive of podcasts right here).
