THE EARLIEST REFERENCES to people cultivating bushes date again to perhaps 6000 BC, and there are information of tree-care ways within the Bible, too, and from historic Egypt. These person-to-tree interventions had been the beginning of the science and artwork of arboriculture, and our greatest practices of pruning and different how-to have developed in every successive period to the strategies we all know right now.
I took a glance backward in historical past, and in addition explored some present suggestions, with Melissa Finley, New York Botanical Backyard’s Thain Curator of Woody Vegetation, and in addition curator of NYBG’s Peggy Rockefeller Rose Backyard.
Woody vegetation are Melissa’s ardour; she is a licensed arborist, and was a forester with the New York Metropolis Division of Parks and Recreation earlier than becoming a member of NYBG 4 years in the past.
Learn alongside as you take heed to the Dec. 22, 2025 version of my public-radio present and podcast utilizing the participant beneath. You may subscribe to all future editions on Apple Podcasts (iTunes) or Spotify (and browse my archive of podcasts right here).
woody plant historical past and how-to, with melissa finley
Obtain file | Play in new window |
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify
Margaret Roach: How are you on this craziest of winters to this point, huh? [Laughter.] Up and down, up and down.
Melissa Finley: It’s so unpredictable. I can’t consider how onerous it was raining about 10 minutes in the past, and 55 levels.
Margaret: Yeah. Insanity, insanity. So talking of tree care, just a bit background: Roughly what number of zillion bushes and shrubs are there at that botanical backyard that you simply and your crew must take care of [laughter]?
Melissa: What a posh query. I believe we have now about 5,000 mapped bushes and shrubs, however many extra which can be unmapped and sort of unverified, hanging out in our woodlands and pure areas. So it’s onerous to guess.
Margaret: You higher keep in your toes, you guys. I consider having a small variety of bushes and shrubs as an enormous accountability, however that’s epic.
Melissa: We keep busy, positively.
Margaret: Yeah. So I believed we may begin with just some highlights of the historical past of mankind’s makes an attempt to handle bushes. I do know we may do 10 entire episodes of the present on completely different theories and types that we’ve developed by means of the ages, however I needed to listen to some that basically stand out to you as a result of I imply, I believe bushes have been on the earth near 400 million years or one thing. We homo sapiens are extra like, I don’t know, what, just a few hundred thousand years or one thing [laughter]. In order that they’ve been round rather a lot longer than we have now. However what, we’ve been cultivating them for six,000 years or one thing. So any highlights for you?
Melissa: Yeah. So I turned concerned about this sort of early historical past of our relationship to bushes after I learn some articles simply in regards to the historical past of American arboriculture and the way we got here to do our up to date practices of tree pruning and located that the essential articles that had been accessible actually stopped quick within the late nineteenth century. So I actually needed to do a deep dive on how folks considered bushes and approached their relationship to bushes a lot additional again.
In order you talked about, yeah, our earliest cultivation practices that we have now information of are about 6000 BC in Asia Minor, however these information actually do prolong. That is early olive tree cultivation shifting from Asia Minor into Italy by the sixth century BC, which is simply outstanding, unfathomable actually period of time.
And the opposite issues I used to be searching for had been simply early mentions of intentional pruning. There are a number of sort of references to pruning of fig bushes within the Bible. They name it “dressing of sycamores,” which refers to Ficus sycomorus, which is the sycamore fig tree.
After which the opposite very early mentions that we discover within the historic information, which I believe had been simply fabulous, had been really from historic Egypt. We’ve these great work and information of truly the transplanting of enormous bushes by the traditional Egyptians. There’s information from the fifteenth century [BC], which was in the course of the reign of Hatshepsut, who was a really well-known feminine pharaoh. And he or she had despatched folks on an expedition to what we expect might be modern-day Somalia to deliver again frankincense and myrrh bushes to be used in rituals. They extract these resins for mummy embalming, and there’s all these information of them very efficiently transplanting these bushes, which to us appears so trendy.
Margaret: Sure. Oh, completely [laughter]. Wow. So I didn’t even know there was a feminine pharaoh, not to mention that she was into transplanting, to having some bushes transplanted.
Melissa: She’s very attention-grabbing.
Margaret: Oh, fascinating. So a protracted historical past, and it’s gone by means of loads of … It’s developed; the practices have developed. And I imply, I’d think about the instruments have developed, clearly. There have been no chainsaws and every kind of issues we have now right now [laughter], huge buckets that went up into the treetops and so forth.
So that you gave me, after we first spoke about this simply on the cellphone a few weeks again or no matter, some actually attention-grabbing analysis papers to learn. And it appeared like one of many topics that had probably the most sort of variations was the pruning of mature bushes, versus the coaching of younger bushes after they’re first getting began. It appeared like with the older bushes, there was much more, effectively, disparity, nearly variations of tactical approaches. Is that the case?
Melissa: Sure, positively. I believe as we’ve been capable of codify our scientific approaches to pruning, that the way in which that we deal with mature bushes has much more … I’m attempting to think about one of the simplest ways to place it. Much more [laughter] sort of disagreement, I’ll say, within the area about the right way to strategy this stuff. I imply, bushes are very onerous to check, and significantly mature bushes. It’s onerous to do a PhD on the way in which that pruning impacts a mature tree whenever you actually do wish to come again not one 12 months later or two years later, however 20 years later [laughter]. How will we do this type of scientific examine in that lengthy of time period may be very tough. So loads of it’s short-term statement and making use of that as finest we will to long-term understanding, which makes all of it very tough, sure.
Margaret: And I imply, I do know loads of arborists from the work I’ve achieved through the years, after which additionally arborists the place I stay, who I’ve employed to assist me with issues which can be too huge for me to do with bushes, with older bushes. And there’s loads of distinction of opinion as a client, as a backyard proprietor who wants assist. And there’s phrases that get thrown out, phrases that get thrown out: What’s structural pruning? After which I lately have heard about retrenchment pruning, and plenty of what looks as if disagreement about that [laughter]. And it’s onerous for the buyer to know what’s the correct means.
Melissa: It’s. And sadly, it’s tough for the professional to know the correct means as effectively [laughter]. What I’ll say is fortunately for the house pruner, bushes which you could attain are usually youthful bushes, and people suggestions haven’t modified very a lot in the previous few years. That’s what we might name structural or formative pruning. Once we’re approaching a juvenile tree, we’re attempting to ascertain a construction that might be long-lasting, that may permit for correct spacing between branches and scale back the cases of the formation of bark inclusions and different issues that may grow to be what we might think about hazardous sooner or later. In order that’s sort of what we imply after we’re speaking about structural pruning.
Margaret: So like within the previous days, we used to say the three D’s: useless, broken and diseased, or some folks had different ones—issues like crossed branches or inward-facing branches, or as you say, issues that had been a possible hazard. These are all structural issues?
Melissa: Sure, completely. So loads of that comes out of the analysis from Ed Gilman, who’s a unbelievable researcher down on the College of Florida, and he did loads of analysis on younger tree structural pruning, and that’s the place loads of these phrases come from. I believe he may need even coined the three D’s, and that’s all sort of bog-standard since I don’t know the way way back, however his analysis has actually proved that it appears to be good follow.
So yeah, you wish to begin along with your three D’s: Get rid of crossers, after which take an enormous step again, put your noticed down, and take a look at what you’ve left after you’ve eradicated these, and actually simply serious about spacing and the general form of the cover. So all of that’s just about nonetheless beneficial. However after we get into the mature bushes, that’s when it will get actually way more advanced.
Margaret: Sure. And so I’ve adopted the work of some practitioners who actually honor the tree by means of its entire life cycle, together with by means of its decline into its demise and its position within the ecosystem as this biomass that was birthed there and lived there and can die there. And except there’s grave hazard to folks or constructions they let it do its factor, so to talk. After which I’ve additionally, once more, met individuals who wish to do changes to the cover even of older bushes or … and I by no means know [laughter] what’s the correct thought.
Melissa: Yeah. So what I’ll say is I believe the newer analysis we have now increasingly is pointing to this unimaginable resilience that we have now in bushes all through their entire lives. So within the … I’m attempting to recollect when this analysis was. There was some analysis achieved about tree life levels, the place they had been describing every part of a tree’s life, as you say, as they go from younger to mature to over-mature and historic and begin to crumble, that describe these as inherent type of developmental levels.
And what the sort of newer analysis is exhibiting is that it’s actually finest to consider a number of of these phases as response phases, and never a lot all the time going to occur at such and such age, at such and such interval of a tree’s life. In order it’s beginning to decline, or change its cover form, these are indicators that the tree is responding to the world round it, to the situations it’s experiencing, and is definitely actively reiterating its cover in new methods in response to that setting.
So the bushes are actually, actually resilient. They’re very perceptive of the world round them, they usually’re rising new wooden, new constructions in response to altering climate and to altering department shapes and every kind of issues. And the sector is attempting to actually perceive how bushes are shaping themselves. And so over-pruning is, I believe … I get it; I really feel that must prune these giant bushes with a purpose to really feel safer. However I believe I sort of have a tendency towards the facet of trusting them to reiterate themselves and adapt to their setting over time as finest we will.
Margaret: After which all the way down to the extent of the person cuts through the years, I’ve heard completely different … Clearly, there’s some very well-known diagrams. I believe a few of them come from Alex Shigo or somebody alongside the way in which that taught loads of this. And we hear about issues just like the … effectively, I used to be taught it was referred to as the branch-bark collar, however perhaps it’s simply the bark collar. And flush cuts and the way these trigger larger wounds. What about after we get to that type of, O.Ok., I’m going to make a lower for a specific purpose? And there are some tree species which have very distinctive distinction within the look of their tissue the place the department meets the trunk and a few that don’t. It’s rather a lot [laughter].
Melissa: Proper. Yeah, completely. So yeah, it was quite common follow to advocate flush-cutting for a really very long time. The oldest point out of it that I may discover was from a ebook revealed in 1861 by a person referred to as de Courval. I’m not going to attempt to pronounce the French. I’ll completely butcher it.
Margaret: I’m horrible at French, so overlook it. I don’t thoughts.
Melissa: However the English translation [by A. Des Cars], which was revealed later, was titled “A Treatise on Pruning Forest and Decorative Timber.” And he was advocating for flush-cutting, which is slicing past that branch-bark ridge, straight into the trunk tissue, so that you simply get as flat a lower as attainable. And his argument is that slicing that shut and even with the trunk will permit for extra sap entry to that wound, for the reason that sap is flowing upward within the xylem of the tree, the vascular tissues of the tree, that having it lower flush towards that trunk will expose the entire wound edges to actively flowing sap and would due to this fact shut quicker.
Which is sensible. And so they have really achieved research that flush cuts, these wound edges do begin to seal over quicker. However as a result of they’re a bigger wound floor, over the course of about 10 years, they’ve achieved these A/B testing and proven that ultimately the branch-bark ridge intact cuts do seal utterly over a lot quicker.
However I used to be very concerned about discovering out why they had been recommending that. And it actually does make sense. It’s accessing that sap, that lively wooden, would possibly trigger quicker regrowth.
Margaret: However now do most arborists go towards the skin the collar, exterior the ridge?
Melissa: Appropriate. Yeah. So that every one comes from Alex Shigo’s analysis, which was simply elementary in restructuring our understanding of bushes. We needed to wait till we may take a look at bushes with just a little finer microscope, and it needed to wait till we had chainsaws, principally [laughter]. It allowed him to actually lastly lower bushes and take a look at completely different cross-sections with rather a lot finer view, way more refinement to these cuts with a chainsaw. It’s an unbelievable scientific instrument, in case you can consider it.
So he began advocating in his 1977 report, “Compartmentalization of Decay in Timber,” this follow referred to as pure goal pruning. So it’s changing this flush lower proper towards that stem of the tree with as a substitute slicing simply exterior what you confer with because the branch-bark ridge. So it leaves just a bit little bit of a nub on the skin there. And the argument is that it each reduces the scale of the lower, that cross-section of wounded wooden, and it retains this very specialised wooden, which analysis has proven has this means, the specialised means, to assist seal over to occlude that wound significantly better than the stem tissue does.
Margaret: Oh. That’s the compartmentalization, is that place is a particular place and it …?
Melissa: Yeah. In order that tissue is significantly better at directing the chemistry of the tree to deposit microbe-fighting chemical compounds, and to bodily seal off elements of the wooden by depositing gums and simply bodily shutting off that space from air. All of those invading fungus particularly actually wants air to stay. So in case you seal off with gums and all kinds of cool waxes, it’s capable of actually functionally make a brand new wall. And that exact space of wooden is way more bodily and chemically capable of do these features.
Margaret: So talking of Twentieth-century developments, did we do issues like cabling and so forth earlier than then, or is {that a} modern-day factor? I imply, as a result of there at the moment are help strategies, too, that I see extra generally utilized.
Melissa: Proper, proper. Nicely, so the metal cabling, which is a quite common follow, that was invented by John Davey, who was an English arborist who moved to the U.S. within the 1870s, and he wrote a ebook referred to as “The Tree Physician” in 1901, which launched a few of these metal cabling and metal brace rod strategies, however it’s really a a lot older strategy. We’ve some proof of the Greeks and Romans doing strategies like grafting and cabling and simply sort of tying collectively orchard and olive and winery vegetation, and monks additionally mentioning it all through the medieval interval. But it surely was way more standardized within the early Twentieth century by folks like John Davey and Francis Bartlett, in all probability the 2 most well-known arborists from America.
Margaret: Whose names then turned the title synonymous with giant tree corporations, Davey Tree and Bartlett [laughter].
Melissa: That’s proper.
Margaret: Oh, I didn’t know that it had an previous historical past earlier than that. That’s attention-grabbing.
I needed to ask you: Again on the botanical backyard, are there tree species that take probably the most sources by way of your crew, your arborist crew, your tree-care crew there? Are there sure high-need sort genera of bushes versus low-need? Are you aware what I imply?
Melissa: Positive, positive. I imply, it’s an attention-grabbing query. Yeah. I imply, I believe simply trying on the bushes themselves, I’d say the primary factor that we’re all the time responding to is white pines dropping their branches [laughter]. And it’s a beautiful adaptation. They’re tailored to alpine situations, frequent snow and ice loading and excessive winds. And reasonably than sustaining a lot larger harm, they only are tailored to permit their branches to interrupt off, sort of brittle and really simply, to guard themselves. However yeah, they do make an enormous fiddle right here fairly regularly.
After which the broader query actually is extra about placement. So I’ve manufactured a reasonably advanced system of inspections for security for our bushes, and that’s primarily knowledgeable by the placement of the tree and the way many individuals are sometimes round it, reasonably than the tree itself. So if it’s over a bench or an out of doors amphitheater or one thing like that, these are bushes that I’m way more, and pruning way more conservatively.
Margaret: High precedence. As a result of for me, I’d have guessed—and once more, I’m a gardener; it’s not as in depth a group by any means—however sure forms of bushes, like I’ve some very, very previous apple bushes and I’ve various previous magnolias. The place they’ve had wounds, so to talk, on their branches, they appear to are inclined to get loads of water-sprouty, sort of “unhealthy hair day”-looking progress [laughter].
Melissa: Sure, they do.
Margaret: And that to me is loads of work, and particularly as soon as they’re huge; you need to stand up in them, and it’s loads of work. So sure vegetation, sure bushes, appear to have that response greater than others. I don’t see these vertical shoots as a lot in different species. And once more, I solely know these two as a result of I’ve them right here. I’m positive there are others that you realize that do this.
Melissa: Oh, and people could be those that I’d have talked about, too. Completely. Crabapples and cherries, the Rosaceous orchard vegetation, are very vulnerable to water sprouts and root sprouts, in addition to magnolias, relying on the hybrid mother and father, as effectively. I’ve discovered that loads of the yellow-flowered magnolias are vulnerable to it, and that’s from that parentage from the Magnolia acuminata, the cucumber tree.
Margaret: And are your crews out doing sure pruning duties now, or do you wait till late winter? Is that this a year-round factor or is it-
Melissa: Yeah, I imply, I believe in one of the best of all worlds, we might be ready till late winter to do pruning. However we have now, as I’m positive you’ll be able to guess, loads of pruning to do [laughter]. So we do prune all through a lot of the dormant season, and naturally do emergency pruning all year long. However sure, now is an efficient time you probably have a protracted checklist of issues to prune, however in case you can wait till the tip of the season, early spring or late winter is a greater time, because you’re not leaving a type of gaping wound that the tree isn’t capable of begin responding to. I believe it offers it a greater likelihood. However yeah, we are going to begin moving into our water-sprout pruning on our crabapples and cherries as we get into the season for positive.
Margaret: Oh, that may go on eternally, positively.
Melissa: [Laughter.] Even right here. It’s a continuing battle.
Margaret: I all the time suppose to myself, I want I had a use for all these very straight younger twigs. And I hold considering, oh, I ought to make what we used to name pea brush, the place you’d poke them within the floor and “brush up” your peas whenever you grew peas, versus placing them on a trellis. That was very English, a really British, old school factor. I’ve by no means achieved that with them, however boy, oh boy, it’s loads of twigs.
Melissa: There’s received to be a terrific craft for it [laughter].
Margaret: I do know. Nicely, if it had been willows, proper, we may make some baskets, couldn’t we? There you go. Melissa. Nicely, I’m so to … I by no means actually considered the historical past half, and I used to be glad that you simply type of turned me onto it and received me studying some references about it, and I’m glad to speak to you once more. So comfortable year-end and New 12 months to return, and thanks for making time right now.
Melissa: In fact. Comfortable New 12 months, and thanks a lot for having me.
favor the podcast model of the present?
MY WEEKLY public-radio present, rated a “top-5 backyard podcast” by “The Guardian” newspaper within the UK, started its sixteenth 12 months in March 2025. It’s produced at Robin Hood Radio, the smallest NPR station within the nation. Hear regionally within the Hudson Valley (NY)-Berkshires (MA)-Litchfield Hills (CT) Mondays at 8:30 AM Japanese, rerun at 8:30 Saturdays. Or play the Dec. 22, 2025 present utilizing the participant close to the highest of this transcript. You may subscribe to all future editions on iTunes/Apple Podcasts or Spotify (and browse my archive of podcasts right here).
